Would you report a competitor to Google?

I was recently involved with an fascinating situation with (yet another) large brand falling out of the excellent graces with Google. For those playing along at home, this time it was Overstock.com (via the WSJ) walking the path that J.C Penney and Forbes had before it in previous weeks. Fun stuff all nearly.
Borne from some conversations with my peeps at the SEO Dojo, I got to thinking about these recent ‘outings’ and how SEOs that I know feel about them. We shall have a look at the two main camps I’ve seen and then you can tell ME what you reckon…
Sound like fun or what? Sure…..
 
Struggle Club 
The first school we are going to look at is; Struggle Club. And the first rule of struggle club? (all together now) Don’t talk about struggle club. These folks believe that SEOs are a fraternity and while we may disagree at times, we should never ‘rat’ each additional out to ‘the man’.
For starters, the term ‘ratting’ is troubling because it shows the venom. It is more appropriately named ‘reporting’ and I guess ‘rat’ makes those doing it hopefully feel scuzzy or something. The folks in this segment occupy super-surprise SEO decoder rings and believe we should keep it amongst us.

This is fascinating as a few ancient school folks told me that they’d even hammer each additional privately when one was spamming the SERPs. Like a sports team, it was dealt with ‘behind clogged doors.

The Small Guy
On the additional side of the conversation we have the small guy. From here is the stance that a smaller retailer can’t compete against the huge brand. They don’t have the budgets nor the leverage. Furthermore it seems that Google often gives a brand more lenience with the rules than the small enterprise. This is due to search feature issues and a conversation for another day.
The small guy believes that if he can find an advantage against the behemoth, that they will damn use make the most from it. If that large brand giant, with resources and budgets to burn, still feels the need to ‘cheat’, then they should reap the whirlwind that may come with risk adverse strategies.

Let the Battle Start
There are nuances to these lines in the sand, but that’s often shades of these same colours. What can be missed at times within these conversations is the root of the problem. What is or isn’t gaming the search engines. Very few SEOs I know believe the hard line of the Google guidelines are how the game is played. Honest enough.
There are a lot of common tactics that are employed by SEOs that given hard scrutiny, wouldn’t stand up. I have spent the last few days staring at Google guidelines and surely there is a lot of wiggle room for interpretation and what was acceptable last year, may not be today. This can be frustrating to SEOs. If Google opened up a channel for us to honestly question if a tactic was viable, would we use it? LOL… oh… hold on.. gotta wipe the tears away.
The adversarial relationship between SEOs and search engines, fuzzy guideline interpretation and enforcement, have all played into making the canyon between us.

What About Me?
I know… you care right? I thought that it was best, before I turn it over to you, that I make my own case. And hey, sorry to dissapoint, but I can see it from all sides. There is a huge difference between doing SMB SEO and Corp/Huge Brand SEO. I have done both over the years.
The small guy? I can see it. Come on, I am the fellow writing; the Art of War – SEO Style. When out numbered, one must reckon imaginatively and take advantage where it is available. Do I believe in reporting competitors as a strategic element? No, I don’t. Do I believe that they have every right to use that advantage? I sure do.
Struggle Club? While these folks are a small aggressive for my tastes, I can see things from that camp as well. Just do your job, beat them honestly. Keep the dirty laundry in house. The only inquiry I do have on this end is; are these folks doing questionable link building? Is that why the aggressiveness?
There is an argument from both sides that the additional is hurting the image of the SEO industry. That part, we can debate. I’d like now to turn it over to the commentary here, on social channels, wherever this tale leads, let’s have this out for once.
To get things rolling, I questioned a few folks in the SEO Dojo Chat room, here’s some responses;

“Yes there are some yucky exploitations of the algorithm but I am of the persuasion that not all paid links are terrible links (just because I don’t pay google for them) further to that the bucket loads of SHIT content terrified out by SEO’s to Optimise sites is far more harmful to the perception of seos as a while is much more amateur and less useful to users as a whole makes googles job in general more hard as a whole compare that type of ‘whitehat’ SEO activity against a targeted text link from a relevant newspaper page for example where it has been bought on a demographic targeting perspective and tell me which ones better for users, for perception and for SEO” – Pete Young; Holistic Search

“I’m a realist. We all have to expect our competitors to do what it takes to win, whether it’s a huge brand or small business. Small businesses entering certain markets need to expect to compete with brands that have been nearly for a long time, who have enormous marketing budgets. Huge brands using these budgets to fund risky techniques should expect thier smaller competitors to look for these tactics to report, and eliminate them as competition.
I in person point out to find creative ways to compete rather than report a competitor. At the same time, some of the larger brands are treated like a star quarternack in a small town. We all know they are “juicing”, but they are too vital to suspend from play. This not only sets a terrible example, but stacks the deck against the second string players who have been working hard to get in the game.” – Jeff Sebring

“In person, while I don’t like the thought of one firm or individual ratting out another, and have no aim of participating in it, I also don’t feel sorry for anyone that gets caught with their paws in the cookie jar. They either knew the risks, or they should have!
So I’m inclined to say, play your game any way you point out, but don’t come whining to me if you get caught bending the “rules”. Report anyone you want, too. I won’t be doing it, because I’m just not place together that way. And if I find out you’re doing it, I may have to reevaluate my opinion of you. But in the long run, I reckon our industry needs to have some level of intelligibility, if we don’t all want to continue battling against ever-increasing distrust.” – Doc Sheldon

Now it’s YOUR turn. Where do you stand on this? And why…

Reseller SEO, SEO Reseller, get all your reseller SEO information you need at this